Archives: Product Reviews

Woocommerce product reviews

2005 and 2004 Red Burgundies (Mar 2007)

(est. 2,500-$2,900) Good deep red. Less expressive but still utterly sexy nose offers plum, raspberry, flowers, smoke and earth. Hints at its superb volume but this is quite closed and tightly knit today, and much less expressive and sweet than La Tache. But this superconcentrated wine seemed to gain sweetness with aeration, showing an increasingly…

2018 Burgundy: Confounded Expectations (Jan 2020)

The 2018 Romanée-Conti Grand Cru sports a limpid ruby color. It is quintessential "RC" on the nose, which features crystalline scents of wild strawberry and cranberry fruit, crushed limestone, oyster shell and pressed rose petal. With aeration there is even a suggestion of crushed flint. The palate is medium-bodied with super-fine tannins that frame the…

The Most and Least Important of Things: Petrus 1897–2011 (Jul 2020)

The 1998 Petrus never fails to deliver. This is a fabulous example that confirms it is a true tour de force. It has a compelling bouquet with mineral-rich black and red fruit with unerring purity. In this bottle, I notice a hint of hickory not observed previously. The palate is medium-bodied with silky smooth tannins,…

1999, 1998 and 1997 Bordeaux (May 2000)

Saturated ruby-red. Multidimensional nose melds black raspberry, mulberry, toffee, minerals, rose petal and roasted oak. Great sweetness, volume and depth; thick but magically light on its feet. Grows broader on the back half with no loss of shape. Firm underlying backbone is currently hidden by seamless fruit. Finishes with big but noble tannins and terrific…

Brilliance in Napa Valley: 2016 & 2015 Cabernets (Jan 2018)

The 2015 Maya is surprisingly powerful and tightly wound. Time in the glass allows the tannins to relax just enough for the fruit to gradually emerge. Like all of the 2015s here, the Maya is still very primary in its expression of fruit. Even so, the wine’s heady, flamboyant personality is very much on display….

Napa Valley’s 2022 & 2023 Cabernet Sauvignons (Dec 2024)

The 2020 Promontory is one of the unqualified successes of this challenging growing season—so much so that I can only conclude that the bottle I tasted in 2023 was not at all representative. Dark cherry, plum, espresso and menthol fill out the layers. There's some edginess in the tannin, but that is a relatively small…